True plastic-free pet food packaging is rare, because most dog food bags, including many that look like paper, contain a plastic layer. The practical way to shop is to read the material, not the picture on the front, and to choose food that is shelf-stable and packed with less waste in mind. We make freeze-dried raw dog food with sustainable packaging, so this is a question we think about a lot. Here is how to sort the real claims from the green-looking ones.
TL;DR
- Many “paper” pet food bags still have a plastic liner, so the outer look tells you little about what is inside the layers.
- “Compostable” usually means industrial composting, which many towns do not offer. Home composting is generally not recommended unless the label says so.
- Most dry pet food bags cannot go in curbside recycling or store drop-off bins. Steel and aluminum cans can.
- A real sustainability claim names the material and the disposal route. Look for third-party certification, not just a leaf icon.
- Freeze-dried food is light and shelf-stable, so it needs no fridge, thawing or ice packs.
Table of Contents
- What “plastic-free” actually means for dog food
- Why the problem is bigger than one bag
- Compostable pet food packaging: what the label does and does not tell you
- Recyclable dog food packaging: what your curbside bin will actually accept
- Why the format of the food matters
- Questions to ask before you buy any dog food
- Where the industry is heading
- Our freeze-dried food, shipped without the cold chain
- Disposal tips that work in any town
- FAQ
- Sources
What “plastic-free” actually means for dog food
A package is plastic-free only if no layer of it is plastic. That includes the film inside a paper bag, the zipper, the seal and the coating that keeps grease and moisture out. Dog food is a hard job for packaging. It has to keep oxygen and moisture away for months and hold several pounds of weight without tearing.
That is why plastic became the default. Packaging World reports an industry consensus around four sustainable paths for pet food packaging: reusable, compostable, mechanically recyclable or chemically recyclable. The same piece notes that many paper pet food bags include a plastic liner, which makes truly plastic-free options hard to find.
So when you see words like “eco,” “earth-friendly” or “made with paper,” treat them as a starting point for a question, not an answer. The questions are simple:
- What is every layer made of?
- Where does the empty package go?
- Is there a certification behind the claim?
Why the problem is bigger than one bag
The scale explains why this matters to so many dog owners. The Pet Sustainability Coalition estimates that about 300 million pounds of pet food and treat packaging waste is generated in the U.S. each year, and over 99% of it ends up in landfills rather than being recycled, as Earth911 reports. The reason is structural. Earth911 explains that most dry pet food bags are made of polypropylene (plastic #5) or multi-layer plastic and aluminum composites, which conventional curbside programs struggle to process.

So the question is not only “is my bag better?” It is also “what happens after I empty it?” A package can be made of a clever material and still end up in a landfill if your town cannot handle it.
Compostable pet food packaging: what the label does and does not tell you
Compostable packaging is made from plant-based or fiber-based materials designed to break down under the right conditions. The words “under the right conditions” are the important part.
Industrial versus home composting
The U.S. EPA says that unless a label states a product is okay for home composting, it should not be composted at home. Compostable plastic is generally intended for industrial or commercial facilities that run at higher temperatures. The EPA also notes that compostable plastics are not meant for recycling, and they can contaminate the recycling stream if mixed with petroleum-based plastics.
If your community has no composting pick-up, the EPA suggests contacting your garbage or recycling company or local government about drop-off locations. If you want to understand how this works in practice, a guide to composting explains why commercial composting differs from a backyard pile.
Access is the catch
Even certified packaging needs somewhere to go. A BioCycle and Composting Consortium survey, cited by the Pulitzer Center, found that only 142 of roughly 200 U.S. industrial composting facilities accepting food waste also accept compostable food-contact packaging. Before you rely on a “compostable” label, check whether a facility near you takes it.
What to look for on the bag
In the U.S., credible compostability claims usually come with third-party certification, such as the Biodegradable Products Institute (BPI) mark, which verifies the product against an industry standard for industrial composting. A leaf symbol or the word “biodegradable” with no certification tells you very little.
For a deeper look at this topic, we also wrote about compostable dog food bags and how compostable and recyclable pet food bags compare in the U.S.
Recyclable dog food packaging: what your curbside bin will actually accept
“Recyclable” is the most misunderstood word on a pet food bag. A material can be recyclable in theory and still be refused by your local program.
The How2Recycle and Wisconsin-based WGPC guide to bags and curbside recycling says flexible bags should stay out of curbside bins, except in the few U.S. communities that accept plastic film, because they can tangle sorting equipment. It also lists most pet food bags and compostable bags as not accepted at store drop-off, where accepted film must be clean and dry. The #2 and #4 numbers you see on curbside lists refer to rigid plastics, not bags.
Local authorities say the same thing. Kane County, Illinois, asks residents to keep plastic film out of curbside carts. Its store drop-off takes only clean, dry #2 and #4 film, and it explicitly lists pet food bags, bags marked #5 or #7 and compostable plastic bags as not accepted. Your own town may differ, so check your city or county recycling page.

There is one clear win. Wet dog food usually comes in steel cans, and Earth911 notes that steel is the most commonly recycled material in the U.S. Rinsed, empty steel and aluminum pet food cans can go in curbside recycling where metal cans are accepted.
A quick way to read a package
| What you see | What it usually means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Paper-look bag, no material named | May have a plastic liner | Look for the layers listed on the package or maker’s site |
| “Compostable” with a certification mark | Built for industrial composting | Confirm a local facility accepts it |
| “Recyclable” on a flexible bag | Often means store drop-off, if at all | Check the drop-off rules, since most pet food bags are excluded |
| Steel or aluminum can | Widely recycled metal | Rinse and recycle where metal cans are accepted |
| Reusable tin or tub | Can be refilled or reused | Keep and reuse for storage |
Why the format of the food matters
The food inside decides which packaging is even possible. Moisture is the enemy of most compostable films. Grounded Packaging’s technical guidance notes that dry and ambient products open up a wider material range, while wet, fresh and frozen foods narrow it, because moisture attacks compostable films.
This is one reason shelf-stable dry formats are a natural fit for lower-waste packaging. Freeze-dried food has the water removed, so it is light and stable at room temperature. That means no fridge, no thawing and no ice packs to ship it, which cuts out the insulated boxes and gel packs that fresh and frozen foods rely on.
Questions to ask before you buy any dog food
Whatever brand you choose, a short checklist keeps you honest:
- Material: Is the full structure named, including liner, zipper and coating?
- Disposal: Does the maker say where the empty package goes, and does that route exist near you?
- Certification: Is a compostable claim backed by a third-party mark?
- Size: Would a bigger bag mean less packaging per meal, and will your dog finish it while fresh?
- Reuse: Can you reuse the container for storage?
Our own checklist for choosing eco-friendly pet food goes through the same questions for the food itself, and our guide to eco-friendly packaging options for freeze-dried dog food shows how the formats compare.
Where the industry is heading
The packaging market is changing. Mordor Intelligence’s 2026 report on the pet food packaging market says the FDA’s withdrawal of 35 PFAS food-contact clearances by January 2025 is pushing paper and board suppliers toward new PFAS-free barriers. PFAS are the “forever chemicals” once used to make paper resist grease. It also notes that state rules in California and Maine create a patchwork that brands must navigate.
For you, the takeaway is that better options are arriving, but they are not all proven for every food. Fiber-based barriers are newer and fit treats and single-serve packs more easily than months of storage for a large bag of kibble. Expect the label to improve over the next few years, and keep reading it carefully until it does.
We started Loyal Saints as a dog mom who wanted better food for her dog and less waste around it. When we talk about packaging, we talk about the whole picture: what is in the bag, how long it keeps, how far it travels and what you do with it afterward.
Our freeze-dried raw food is made with human-grade, whole ingredients, is AAFCO-complete and is shelf-stable, so it needs no fridge, no thawing and no ice packs. Our packaging is sustainable, and we would rather you ask good questions of every label, ours included, than take a green icon on faith.
Our advice is simple. Choose food your dog thrives on, buy the size you will finish while it is fresh, and look at the real material and the real disposal route. Good nutrition and a lighter footprint belong together.
Kristina
Our freeze-dried food, shipped without the cold chain
If you want premium food that keeps at room temperature, our freeze-dried raw dog food comes in three recipes: Beef, Chicken, and Turkey + Salmon. Prices run from $24.95 to $44.95 depending on the size. You can start with a 14 oz chicken bag, a 5 oz chicken bag, or the variety pack of three 14 oz bags to find your dog’s favorite.
The Halo Club membership offers savings and free shipping, at $79.99 per year or $10.99 per month. Standard shipping is $7.99 and express shipping is $14.99, listed on our shipping page.
Disposal tips that work in any town
Good habits matter as much as good materials:
- Empty and keep clean. Recycling programs that accept film want it clean and dry, so shake out crumbs and wipe the bag before you take it anywhere.
- Check local rules first. Search your county’s recycling page for “plastic film” and “compostable packaging.” Rules vary a lot from place to place.
- Keep compostables out of the recycling bin. The EPA says they can contaminate the recycling stream.
- Reuse what you can. A sturdy, clean container can store treats, dry goods or travel portions.
- Buy the right size. Packaging per ounce usually falls as bags get bigger, but only if your dog finishes the food while it is fresh.
Breeders, trainers and shelters buying in larger volumes can use the same checklist. Ask what each layer is, then ask where it goes at the end.
FAQ
Is any dog food packaging truly plastic-free?
A few formats avoid plastic, such as steel or aluminum cans for wet food and some fiber-based packs for treats. For dry food, plastic-free is hard to find because many paper bags carry a plastic liner, as Packaging World reports. Ask the maker to name every layer.
Can I put a compostable dog food bag in my backyard compost?
Only if the label says it is home compostable. The EPA says compostable plastic is generally meant for industrial facilities with higher temperatures. If your area has no pick-up, ask your local government about drop-off sites.
Can I recycle an empty dog food bag at the grocery store?
Usually not. Store drop-offs generally accept clean, dry #2 and #4 film, and most pet food bags are excluded, according to the WGPC guide. Check your local county page before you go.
Does shelf-stable food mean less packaging waste?
It can mean less supporting material. Because freeze-dried food needs no fridge, thawing or ice packs, there is no cold-chain packaging around it. How the bag itself is handled afterward still depends on your local rules.
Sources
- Four Ways Forward for Sustainable Pet Food Packaging, Packaging World
- Recycling Mystery: Pet Food Packaging, Earth911
- Frequently Asked Questions about Plastic Recycling and Composting, U.S. EPA
- Compostable Dog Poop Bags Aren’t Really That Compostable, Pulitzer Center
- Why can’t I put bags in my curbside recycling bin?, WGPC
- Recycling Plastic Bags, Kane County, Illinois
- Pet Food Packaging, Grounded Packaging
- Pet Food Packaging Market Size & Forecast 2026 to 2031, Mordor Intelligence
- A Guide to Composting at Work


